From Krista:
I’m having pretty bad luck with Pinterest projects this week. First the wrapping paper thing and now this. But I guess that’s what happens when you start attempting lots of things you see on Pinterest. I’m trying to do some neat activities with my kids (for more on that, see this post on my other blog, The Playdate Crashers) and we’re using some ideas that we found there — I guess they can’t all be winners.
I needed some finger paint for a craft we did today with my kids. Since they’re 3 and 2, something that won’t kill them if they eat or injest it is preferred. I saw a lot of recipes out there but decided to try this one…PLEASE NOTE: This particular recipe is NOT edible, it contains dishwashing liquid.
What I ended up with was NOT a delightful gel mixture that my children could happily paint with, we had a nasty, watery mess that stained our hands.

It separated into a nasty watery mess and a slimy mess on the bottom. They are separate but equally messy.


We were able to at least stain our white paper into grayish/purplish colors for our elephants we were making. (I made 3 colors, red, green, and black.) They were unusable, so I had to dump it all out.

The only bright side was that it made a nice sink full of bubbles when I washed out all the dishes and containers used. *sigh*
I honestly have no idea what went wrong. I suppose I just didn’t keep it on the heat long enough, but I stirred that sucker on low heat for a long time and it never turned into anything like paint.